The argument which follows suggests that Europe in 1914 was RIPE for
war to break out - that the causes of World War One went back long before
1914, and had so set Europe at odds that it only needed a tiny spark to push
all Europe into war. You will need to
understand, not only WHAT the situation was in 1910-14, but HOW each element
made war more likely...
1. Awful governments
Not only were many of the governments of
Remember also that in these days there was
no idea of going to war for the 'right' reasons - many people in those days
thought it was alright to go to war simply to win more power and territory
for the ruler.
In such a Europe, outbreak of war was less
of an issue than - say - the recent war in
2. Nationalism
EVERYONE was nationalist in those days, and this helped cause war in
two ways:
a. It made the people of
countries like
b. It made the races ruled by
|
Did You Know?
Kaiser Wilhelm had a withered arm and suffered a
slight paralysis which made him unsteady on his feet. To overcome
this, his teachers bullied him; historians think that this led Wilhelm's
unstable and aggressive character - and may have been a contributory factor
to the outbreak of war.
Source A
mother of the free...
God who
made thee mighty,
make thee mightier yet.
The
words of
Compare the German national anthem: Deutschland uber Alles: ‘
Source B
This British postcard shows
the Kaiser taking the 'place in the sun' that wanted.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||
3. Imperialism
Countries who believed that they were superior thought it was alright
to conquer and rule others – particularly if they were inhabited by races
they thought were inferior.
a. This led to clashes between imperialist
powers.
b. Most of all, it led to HUGE tension when Kaiser Wilhelm
of
All the nations of Europe were militaristic, but the governments of
Another thing that the countries of
•
•
•
•
And as one country increased its armies, so all the others felt
obliged to increase their armed forces to keep the ‘balance of power’.
It is important to realise that - although in 1914 the German army was
the biggest and best in the world - the Russian army was growing the fastest,
and German generals were worried that, in a few years time, they would not be
able to defeat
Did You Know?
The
politicians of 1914 did not see - as we do today - the build-up of armed
forces or the system of alliances as threats to peace; they thought that they
would KEEP the peace by acting as a deterrent to any nation thinking of
attacking them.
They believed peace would be kept by a
BALANCE OF POWER between the two alliance blocks.
|
Source C
The German
answer to all our talk about the limitation of armaments is:
I have lived among Germans, but with the best will in the world I can see no
solution to the present collision of ideals but war.
A lecture given in 1913 by JA
Cramb
JA Cramb was an Englishman
who went to university in
Source D
The Naval 'War Cabinet' of 1912
General
von Moltke [head of the army] said:
I believe
war is unavoidable; war the sooner the better. But we ought to do
more to press to prepare the popularity of a war against
From the Diary of Admiral Muller,
Some historians say that this
proves that
New Words
Nationalism: the strong
belief that your nation is better than others.
Imperialism: the desire to
build an empire for the benefit of the mother country.
Militarism: the control of
government and policies by the armed forces, and a willingness to build up
the armed forces and to consider a military solution for foreign relations
problems.
Alliances: treaties of
friendship and support between countries who promise to support each other in
a war.
|
As well as seeking protection in the size of their armies, the
countries of
At first,
Alarmed by this strong central bloc:
a.
b. In 1904
c. In 1907,
d. In 1902
e. The Triple Entente alarmed
The countries of
|
1899-1900:
|
Boer War
|
1900:
|
German Navy Law
|
1905-6:
|
First Moroccan Crisis
|
1908:
|
Daily Telegraph article
|
1908-9:
|
Bosnian crisis
|
1911:
|
Agadir Crisis (2nd Moroccan Crisis)
|
1912-13:
|
Balkan Wars
|
1914
|
Assassination at
|
Extra:
For
each of the background 'pressures-towards-war' 1-5, explain how it helped to
bring war nearer.
The alliances
of Europe in 1914
The countries of Europe in 1914
Turkey
A very weak despotism, ruled by a corrupt government. Turkey was known as ‘the sick man of Europe ’. Once, Turkey had ruled all of
the Balkans, but now the peoples of that area were rebelling and driving the
Turks out – this created a significant area of instability in Europe: ‘the
Balkan pressure-cooker’.
Germany
Austria Hungary
Had once been a strong empire, but now the government was weak and
divided (the Austrians and the Hungarians hated each other). Austria-Hungary
had been built up by marriage and diplomacy during the Middle Ages, and was
known as the ‘polyglot (many languages) empire’ because of all the different
races in it. The Habsburg rulers were stupid and inbred, and
Emperor Franz Josef was old and autocratic.
Italy
A new country formed in 1866. A weak ruler, chaotic
governments and a pathetic army. The Mafia and corruption
everywhere.
Russia
France
Britain
The Growing Crisis, 1900-1914 [BiG FaT BABA]
|
|
Event
|
Effect(s)
|
1. Boer
War 1899-1900
|
·
The British were outraged,
and developed the idea that
|
2. German
Navy Law, 1900
In 1900 Kaiser Wilhelm began to build up the German
navy, announcing that he wanted Germans to sail all over the world and take
for
Did
You Know?
It
has been suggested that imperial rivalries were a long-range cause of World
War I. It has also been said that
they were a safety valve, drawing off European energies that might otherwise
have erupted in war sooner.
|
· The
British thought that
· A
strong navy would also allow
·
·
· By
1914, the British navy was much larger than the German navy, so it is
arguable that this was NOT a cause of World War I.
|
3.
First Moroccan Crisis, 1906
|
·
The
French were furious with
·
The
British saw it as yet another attempt by
·
A
Conference was held at
·
In 1907,
|
4. Telegraph Article, 1908
Kaiser
Wilhelm gave an interview to the Daily Telegraph newspaper, in which -
although he claimed that he wanted to be friends with Britain - he said that
the English were 'mad', said that the German people hated them, and demanded
that: 'Germany must have a powerful fleet to protect her interests in even
the most distant seas'.
Source A
You English, are mad, mad, mad as
March hares. What has come over you that you are so completely
given over to suspicions quite unworthy of a great nation?
...
I have said time after time that I am
a friend of
My task is not the
easiest. The prevailing sentiment among large sections of
the middle and lower classes of my own people is not friendly to
Interview with Kaiser Wilhelm II in the Daily Telegraph,
|
·
The
article outraged the British.
·
It
convinced them that
|
5. Bosnian crisis, 1908
|
·
·
|
6. Agadir Crisis, 1911
There was a revolution in
|
·
The
French and British were furious - the British minister Lloyd
George said that '
·
|
7. Balkan Wars, 1912-13
As
|
·
·
The Kaiser took Sir Edward Grey's co-operation
as a sign of
|
8. Assassination at
|
·
This
started a sequence of events which led to World War One.
|
Extra:
For each of these
'crises' 1-8, explain whether it is an example of:
•
Nationalism
•
Imperialism
•
Militarism
•
Alliances in action.
The Murder of Franz Ferdinand
1. In
2 It was
the Archduke's wedding anniversary. It was also
3 Austrian
spies in
4 To
reach the Town Hall the procession had to drive along the Appel Quay. There
were a few shouts of Zivio! ('Long may he live!') At
5 The
order of conspirators as the procession passed down the Appel Quay was:
Near
the Cumuria bridge:
1st Mehmed Mehmedbasic: told a friend that he could not get a clear opportunity; told
Albertini in 1937 that a policeman had approached him just as he was to throw
the bomb.
2nd Vaso Cubrilovic: told
investigation that felt sorry for the Duchess. Told Albertini that he was badly placed.
3rd Nedeljko Cabrinovic: wearing a long black coat and a black hat, asked a policeman to tell
him which car the Archduke was in; seconds later he had knocked the cap off a
hand grenade against a metal lamp-post and aimed it at the Archduke seated in
the open car. The bomb had bounced
off the folded-back hood of the Archduke's car and blew up the car behind,
killing two officers and injuring about twenty people. Cabrinovic swallowed poison, but it failed
to work. After stopping to see what
had happened, Franz Ferdinand's car sped to the Town Hall.
4th (landward side) Cvetko Popovic: told a friend that could not see FF because he was short-sighted. Told the trial he lost his nerve.
Near the Latin bridge:
5th
Gavrilo Princip: At his trial, said
that the Archduke's car sped past him on its way to the Town Hall after
Cabrinovic's bomb, while he went to see what was happening
At the
6th
Trifko Grabez: Told the investigation that he could not
bring himself to do such a thing. At
the trial stated that two policemen were behind him. Told his friend that he did not want to
wound innocent bystanders.
10 At the
Town Hall, Franz Ferdinand furiously cancelled the rest of the tour. Potiorek (the Austrian Governor) suggested
returning by a different route to the one advertised; however, he forgot to
tell the chauffeurs. On the journey,
therefore, the front car took a right-hand turn into the narrow
11 The
first bullet struck the Archduke, the second - aimed at Potiorek - hit the
Duchess. At first nobody moved. People thought that the assassin had missed.
Then the Duchess slumped forward. The bullet had gone through the side of the
car, her corset and her right side. 'Sopherl! Don't die! Stay alive for our
children!' cried the Archduke, but she died as he spoke. Franz Ferdinand outlived her only a short
time; a bullet had pierced the right side of his coat collar, cut the jugular
vein and lodged in the spine. It was
|
||
Four Steps to
War, June-Aug 1914 [ARSE]
|
||
The nations slithered over the brink
into the boiling cauldron of war without any trace of apprehension or
dismay... The nations backed their machines over the precipice
... not one of them wanted war; certainly not on this scale.
David
Lloyd George, War Memoirs (1934)
Lloyd
George was a minister in 1914 and Prime Minister during the war.
There was no "slide" to
war, no war caused by "inadvertence," but instead a world war
caused by a fearful set of elite statesmen and rulers making deliberate
choices.
Book
review in The American Historical Review of
Richard
F. Hamilton and Holger H. Herwig, The Origins of World War I (2003)
Five weeks after the assassination of Franz Ferdinand on
How did such a thing happen?
|
||
What was
So the assassination was used by
5 July:
23 July: The Austro-Hungarian government sent
25 July: But the Serb government did not reject the
ultimatum. Instead it sent a reply in which it agreed to
everything EXCEPT part of demand 6. It was SO conciliatory that,
after reading it, Kaiser Wilhelm wrote on 28 July: 'the reply amounted to a
capitulation in the humblest style, and with it there disappeared all reason
for war'.
28 July:
Did
you know?
The historian Paul Schroeder, in 1972, suggested
that the question should not be why war broke out in 1914, but why not
before? What snapped in 1914? The answer, he said, was
|
Source A
The Austrian
government was not much concerned to punish the crime of
|
|
2.
The Serbs had wrong-footed the Austrians. Whereas, on 28
June, everyone in the world had supported the Austrians, now they looked
unfair, unreasonable and war-mad. As the Austrian army shelled
24 July:
29 July: But the Tsar Nicholas had already let down
31 July: At first, Nicholas hoped to
mobilise only against Austria-Hungary, but - when his generals told him that
this was impossible - he was forced to order a general mobilisation (against
Germany as well as Austria-Hungary). However, he sent a telegram
to the Kaiser assuring him that the mobilisation was NOT against
|
Source C
An unjust war has
been declared on a weak country. The anger in
|
|
3. Schlieffen Plan
What was
It is important
to realise that the Schlieffen Plan for mobilisation was a plan of attack -
so
And the
Schlieffen Plan did not allow for a situation like that in 1914.
Things were going wrong for
1 August: The Kaiser, therefore, gave
the order to mobilise and
3 August: claiming that French planes
had bombed the German town of
4 August: with German troops on the
march to invade
|
The Schlieffen Plan
a. If
there was a war,
b.
c.
The
Schlieffen Plan, therefore, was developed as a huge hammer blow at Paris,
using 90% of the German army, which would take France out of the war quickly
(allowing Germany to get its army back to fight Russia).
|
|
4.
|
Source F
The
greatest war of modern times, and perhaps in the whole history of the human
race, was begun by
The
Great War - the Standard History (1914)
A British patriotic magazine
published weekly
|
|
No comments:
Post a Comment